Lenders do not share in your upside, so they underwrite the fallback as much as the business. Here is how collateral is valued, why good companies get refused, and how to structure a request that works.
Picture a founder whose services business has grown profitably for three years. She asks her bank for $500,000 to fund an expansion, and two weeks later the answer arrives: not without security. Across town, a plastics molder with thin margins, an aging customer list and a building it owns outright is approved for twice that amount at a lower rate. It is tempting to read the two outcomes as a ranking of business quality. They are a ranking of something else.
Most commercial lending is built around two questions, and founders tend to hear only the first. Can the business repay out of its own operations? And if it cannot, what does the lender get instead? The second question often decides the size, the price and sometimes the existence of the loan, which is why so many refusals that look irrational make sense once you see how lenders answer it.
A lender only gets the downside
An equity investor can win big if your company triples in value. A lender cannot. Its best case is principal back plus interest at an agreed rate, and its worst case is losing a large part of the principal. Because the occasional windfall never offsets the occasional disaster, lenders are paid for avoiding losses, not for spotting greatness, and that shapes how they underwrite everything.
The primary source of repayment is the cash your business generates. The secondary source is what the lender can take if that fails: collateral it can sell, or guarantees from owners or third parties. Credit committees generally want both to hold. Strong cash flow with nothing behind it looks like a bet that nothing will go wrong. Strong collateral with weak cash flow looks like a plan to become an auctioneer, which lenders dislike because enforcement is slow, expensive and contested.
The primary test is usually the debt service coverage ratio: cash available for debt service divided by scheduled principal and interest. Lenders commonly look for somewhere between 1.2x and 1.5x or more. At exactly 1.0x every spare dollar goes to the lender and a single bad quarter becomes a missed payment. The cushion exists because forecasts tend to be wrong in the same direction.
Collateral is valued in a bad week
Book value is what an accountant recorded. Lending value is what the lender expects to recover if it must sell the asset quickly, from a distressed borrower, to buyers who know it. The gap is the haircut, and the percentage the lender will actually advance against the asset is the advance rate. Receivables from creditworthy customers earn the highest rates, often 70% to 90% of eligible invoices, but invoices over 90 days old, disputed, owed by related parties or concentrated in one customer are usually excluded.
Inventory earns much less, often 30% to 60%, because half-finished or niche goods sell at a steep discount. Equipment is assessed on what an auction would fetch, then lent against at a further percentage. Property is usually lent against at 60% to 80% of an independent valuation, and less for specialized buildings.
Here is a hypothetical. A fastener distributor asks for a $1 million five-year term loan at 10%, and expects operating cash flow before debt service of about $400,000 a year. The lender's view of its assets looks like this.
| Asset | Book value | Lender's assumption | Lending value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Receivables | $600,000 | Exclude $100,000 over 90 days; lend 80% of the remaining $500,000 | $400,000 |
| Inventory | $500,000 | Lend 40% of book value | $200,000 |
| Equipment | $800,000 | Auction value taken at 55% of book ($440,000); lend 80% of that | $352,000 |
| Total | $1,900,000 | Roughly half of book value | $952,000 |
A $1 million loan repaid over five years at 10% costs roughly $264,000 a year in principal and interest, so cash flow of $400,000 gives coverage of about 1.5x. The primary test passes comfortably. The secondary test does not: lending value of $952,000 leaves a $48,000 shortfall. A typical lender resolves that by trimming the loan to about $950,000, asking for a director's guarantee, or taking another asset as security. Nothing about the business improved between those outcomes. What changed was the schedule of assets and how it was valued.
Why the mediocre warehouse wins
Lenders think in expected loss: the probability the borrower defaults, multiplied by the share of the exposure lost when it does. Take two hypothetical borrowers. A profitable software business has a 2% chance of default but little a lender can recover, say 10 cents on the dollar, so it loses 90% when things go wrong. Expected loss is 1.8% of the loan. A mediocre manufacturer has a 4% chance of default, but its machinery and building recover 70 cents on the dollar, so it loses 30%. Expected loss is 1.2%. The weaker business is the safer loan, and a lender who cannot share in the upside has no reason to prefer the better company.
Software and service companies hold their value in code, contracts and people. In a default the people leave, and a recurring revenue stream is hard to seize and sell. Institutional incentives reinforce the caution: internal credit policies, and in many jurisdictions bank capital rules, treat recognized collateral more favorably than unsecured exposure. Some lenders do underwrite recurring revenue, through venture debt or revenue-based structures, but they typically compensate by pricing higher, lending a modest multiple of revenue or asking for warrants. If the upside is what makes your business valuable, equity or quasi-equity may fit better than a bank loan ever will.
Structures that give lenders a fallback
Rather than arguing with the lender's logic, you can borrow in a form that builds the second way out into the deal. Asset finance uses the equipment itself as security, with the lender holding title and the term matched to the asset's useful life, so the asset's output repays the loan. Invoice discounting advances cash against unpaid invoices; the risk shifts toward your customers' credit and the loan pays itself off as they settle. Trade finance funds a specific purchase of goods, often backed by documents such as a letter of credit, and is repaid from the resale. Each turns a general request to trust the business into a loan against a specific, trackable source of repayment. The price is higher fees and tighter lender control over your cash.
Guarantees work from the other direction. In a credit guarantee scheme, a government agency or development institution absorbs part of the loss if the borrower defaults, so the bank can lend against thinner collateral. The US Small Business Administration's 7(a) program, which guarantees a portion of loans made by participating lenders, is a well-known example, and development finance institutions offer partial credit guarantees to local banks that lend to small businesses. Skeptics note that guarantees can subsidize loans banks would have made anyway, so check the eligibility rules, the fees and whether your bank actually uses the scheme.
Guarantees matter most in emerging markets, where registries for movable assets such as inventory, equipment and receivables are often weak and court enforcement can take years. Banks then fall back on land titles and personal guarantees, which tends to shut out asset-light firms, and a guarantee substitutes public credibility for the missing infrastructure. Our piece on funding routes for founders in emerging markets covers other options.
Build the request like a credit memo
A credit officer has to write a memo defending the loan to a committee, and your request is the raw material. The easier you make that memo to write, the better your odds. In practice that means a few things in the package:
- What the loan is for, and how that use generates the cash that repays it.
- Debt service coverage in a base case and a downside, such as revenue down 20% and your slowest customer paying 60 days late.
- A schedule of assets in the lender's terms: book value, age, ownership, existing liens and your own estimate of lending value.
- The second way out, whether assets, a guarantee scheme or an owner's guarantee, and the gap if there is one.
- A tenor matched to what you are financing: revolving lines for working capital, term loans over the life of equipment.
- Existing debt and any other claims on your assets, disclosed up front.
Two terms often arrive late in the conversation. Covenants are the lender's tripwires: a minimum coverage ratio, a cap on total debt, limits on dividends and regular reporting. They let the lender step in while there is still collateral worth protecting. Ask for headroom between the covenant level and your forecast, so ordinary bad months do not trigger a breach, and for a cure period to fix one if it does.
A personal guarantee bridges a collateral shortfall with the owner's own wealth. Rather than signing an unlimited one by default, you can propose one capped at the shortfall, one that falls away after one or two years of clean repayment, or a guarantee scheme in its place. Understand what you are putting at risk and take legal advice, because the treatment of personal assets differs by jurisdiction.
Lenders ask for the same financials, asset schedules and contracts that investors do. Fundverse's data room lets you assemble them once and share them in an organized way.
A refusal is a negotiable number
The next time a bank says no, ask which of the two tests failed. If the coverage ratio fell short, the loan is too large or the business too young, and the conversation is about size and timing. If the collateral fell short, you are looking at a structure problem, and the shortfall is usually a specific figure you can close with an asset pledge, a different instrument or a guarantee.
The question worth asking about your own company is not whether it is good enough to borrow against. It is what a stranger would pay for what you own on its worst day, and how much of that you can show on paper. Founders who can answer precisely tend to find the cheapest capital on the market is available to them after all.
Frequently asked questions
Topics
collateral valuation
advance rate
haircut
SME bank loan
asset-based lending
credit guarantee scheme
personal guarantee
debt service coverage ratio
Raising or investing?
Find the right people on the other side of the table, and run the round in one place.

